Star Academy: Highlights and disappointments of the second prime featuring duos, theater, and unexpected surprises…

The second live show of the Star Academy once again captivated the audience with performances that were at times moving and at others disappointing. Unprecedented duets between artists and students, a touch of theater, as well as unexpected surprises set the rhythm for the evening.

Fans were in turmoil, both from the enchanting performances and from moments that were a bit more controversial. Let’s review the highlights of the evening as well as the small flops that elicited mixed reactions.

The Highlights

Touching Duo between Maïa and Grand Corps Malade

The evening began memorably with the duet between Maïa and Grand Corps Malade. The young academician declared: “This is the most beautiful moment of my life that I just spent here”. The emotion was palpable, and Grand Corps Malade’s velvety voice perfectly supported Maïa’s performance. The singing teacher, Sofia Morgavi, couldn’t hold back her tears, applauding the student’s vulnerability and highlighting the beauty of this interpretation.

A Magical Connection: Ebony and Rag’N’Bone Man

Another memorable moment was the duet between Ebony and Rag’N’Bone Man on the song Human. The performance highlighted a beautiful chemistry between the two artists, with each voice responding harmoniously to the other. After some previous difficulties, Ebony managed to discern the director’s advice and delivered an effortless performance while reminding us of the importance of being oneself on stage.

Ulysse in Ecstasy with Jean-Louis Aubert

For Ulysse, the dream came true when he was able to sing with his idol Jean-Louis Aubert. This duet on Ça (c’est vraiment toi) touched the audience’s heart. The surprise of seeing his father on stage added a touch of emotion to this performance, which, despite a few false notes, managed to captivate the audience with the energy conveyed.

The Disappointments

A Duo Lacking Emotion: Franck and Maïa

On the other hand, the cover of Les Feux d’artifice by Franck and Maïa left a bitter taste. This song, rich in meaning and memory, did not find the expected impact. The performance lacked precision and emotion, thus diluting the tribute it was meant to pay to the victims of the Nice attack. The audience felt this, and disappointment was palpable.

Wannabe: An Unbalanced Ensemble

The performance of Wannabe by the Spice Girls also sparked debate. Although the atmosphere seemed friendly, the academicians Emma, Marguerite, Ebony, and Maïa were somewhat overshadowed by the presence of Lénie, who came from the 2023 class. This impression of being sidelined altered the perception of some spectators, leading to criticisms that attention was diverted from the current year’s academicians, which is unfortunate.

The Unexpected Surprises

A Theatrical Touch with Julie and Charles

The theatrical challenge of Julie and Charles, who portrayed elderly characters to sing Les vieux mariés by Michel Sardou, elicited mixed reactions. While the originality of the performance was praised, the AI-generated backgrounds seemed to distract from the performance itself. This distraction sometimes interfered, overshadowing the beautiful harmony sung between the two academicians.

A Medley That Struggles to Convince

The academics’ participation in a disco medley with Nikos Aliagas also divided opinions. Despite the promise of a festive atmosphere, the false notes tarnished the performance. Spectators mainly noticed that Nikos’s integration seemed more anecdotal than relevant, leaving a feeling of incompleteness.

In summary, the second live show of the Star Academy delivered on its promises by offering a colorful array of performances, while not being free from flaws. The contrasts between strong emotions and somewhat reductive moments invite reflection. What was your favorite moment? Which performances disappointed you? Feel free to share your thoughts and debate in the comments.